The American Dream and Promise Act of 2025 could create a pathway to permanent legal status for millions of immigrants and is one signature away from reaching a congressional threshold, as undocumented residents who have spent years living and working in the United States continue to face significant legal barriers to obtaining residency and citizenship.
The legislation, introduced by Rep. Sylvia Garcia, D-Texas, looks to help certain undocumented immigrants obtain lawful permanent residency. One of these groups is recipients of Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA), a program established in 2012 that provides temporary protection from deportation and employment authorization to eligible individuals brought to the country as children.
However, DACA does not grant lawful immigration status or provide recipients with an automatic pathway to permanent residency or citizenship. Similarly, Temporary Protected Status (TPS) allows eligible individuals from certain designated countries to remain and work in the United States temporarily, but the designation does not independently establish a pathway to citizenship.
Under the proposed legislation, qualifying Dreamers could pursue conditional permanent residency and eventually obtain unconditional permanent residency after meeting additional requirements. Certain TPS and Deferred Enforced Departure (DED) beneficiaries could also become eligible for lawful permanent residency.
These changes would not automatically grant citizenship. Instead, they would establish opportunities for eligible immigrants to obtain permanent legal status, after which they could pursue naturalization if they meet the applicable requirements.
The legislation also contains eligibility restrictions, meaning not every undocumented immigrant would qualify. For agricultural communities such as Kern County, where immigrant labor plays an important role in the local economy, the limitations of existing pathways to citizenship remain particularly relevant.
Ambar Tovar, an immigration attorney with the United Farm Workers (UFW), said the options currently available to undocumented immigrants who have lived in the United States for years, or even decades, are often extremely limited.
“Really, there are very limited options for them to regularize their status. Usually most people regularize their status through family petitions, meaning that they have a sibling, a spouse, a child or a parent who can petition for them,” Tovar said.
Although family-based immigration petitions can provide a route toward permanent residency, Tovar explained that having a qualifying relative does not necessarily mean an undocumented immigrant can obtain legal status without encountering additional legal barriers.
For example, a U.S. citizen who is at least 21 years old may petition for an undocumented parent. However, depending on how that parent entered the country and their immigration history, they may be required to leave the United States to complete an immigrant visa interview at a U.S. embassy or consulate abroad.
For individuals who have accumulated more than one year of unlawful presence, leaving the country can trigger a 10-year bar on reentry. Although waivers are available in certain circumstances, obtaining one requires meeting additional legal requirements and is not guaranteed.
“And so it’s not that easy for people to just say, marry a US citizen or your US citizen child can petition for you. That is not the case for the majority of the people in that situation,” Tovar said. “Most people are subject to that 10-year bar that then makes it very difficult for them to be able to return to the United States.”
The possibility of being separated from family members for an extended period can discourage some undocumented immigrants from pursuing legal options, particularly those who have spent much of their adult lives establishing families and working in the United States.
“Most people don’t even try. Once they hear that they may be subject to a 10 year bar that forces them to be out of the country for 10 years, they’re like, well, no, I don’t want to try. I can’t be separated from my children,” Tovar said. “I can’t be separated from my spouse, whatever the situation might be. And so the options are extremely, extremely limited.”
Supporters of the legislation are attempting to bring it to a vote in the House of Representatives through a discharge petition, a congressional procedure that can allow lawmakers to advance legislation without approval from House leadership. As of Wednesday, November 18, the petition had collected 217 of the 218 signatures required to initiate that process, according to the U.S. House Clerk’s official records.
The congressional debate comes as federal immigration authorities are also facing scrutiny over a significant decline in naturalization approvals.
According to an October 23 report by The Washington Post, federal immigration officials approved approximately 173,000 people for citizenship during the first eight months of 2026, representing a 72% decrease compared with the same period in 2025.
The report also found that the backlog of pending naturalization applications had surpassed 800,000 cases as of August 2026, leaving hundreds of thousands of applicants awaiting decisions.
Tovar said one of the most common misconceptions about immigration law is the assumption that undocumented immigrants can simply apply for legal status after spending enough time in the United States.
“I cannot tell you how many comments I have read about, you know, people who are questioning, why is it that this person has been in the country for 20 years? You know, couldn’t they have, you know, applied for a benefit in those 20 years?” Tovar said.
She explained that the answer is often more complicated than people realize because there may be no immigration benefit for which someone qualifies, no matter how many years they have lived in the country.
“The reality and the answer is no. There is a reason why there are undocumented people in the US that have been here for 20, 30 years without an opportunity to apply for status because there is no such opportunity to apply for status,” Tovar said. “It’s not as easy as lining up at the DMV to obtain a driver’s license.”